A Clash of Kings (Song of Ice and Fire) - Books (George R.R. Martin, Paperback)

George R.R. Martin writes sword-and-sorcery which concentrates on the swords. A Clash of Kings is the second volume of A Song of Ice and Fire, the sequence which began with A Game of Thrones and will take another four volumes to complete. The Seven Kingdoms are divided by revolt and blood feud; beyond their Northern borders, the men of the Night Watch fight the coming of a great cold and the walking corpses that travel with it; on the other side of the ocean, the last of the Kingdom's deposed ruling house mourns her horseclan husband and rears the dragonlets she hatched from his funeral pyre. This is character-driven fantasy--we see most events through the eyes of the sons and daughters of the Stark family, the once and future Kings of the North, whose father's judicial murder started the war. Martin avoids the cosy Californian cheeriness of many epic fantasies in favour of a sense of the squalor and grandeur of high medieval life; there is passion here, and misery and charm--and a profound sense of moral ambiguity as we learn to like the Richard III figure in this epic as much as the more virtuous Starks. --Roz Kaveney

Customer Reviews of A Clash of Kings (Song of Ice and Fire)

Mr. G. Firth

31st December 2008

Epic tale
I'm working my way through this epic series, having struggled to get into the first book. It's certainly been a worthwhile experience as I now recognise that this is the work of a genius. Try it, you won't be disappointed

L. Ferguson
Galway Ireland
19th June 2008

Gripping but....
Picking up right where 'A Game of Thrones' left off, 'A Clash of Kings' is just as gripping as its predecessor and is a very captivating book. The series main strength is the presence of some fantastic characters, most notably Tyrion Lannister, one of the best anti-heroes I've come across in fiction. One thing that must be made quite apparent though is that one should utterly ignore the ridiculous quote on some versions of his books that George RR Martin is 'the American Tolkien.' Other than the fact that they both have two 'R's' in their name and have books on sale in the 'Fantasy' section of your local bookshop, there is no call for comparison. Tolkien invented modern fantasy and set out a template which far too many authors have simply ripped off (the unlikely hero, the quest, the band of heroes etc.) Martin deliberatley ignores or subverts these conventions and indeed his work is much closer, in the main, to historical fiction. To sum up; there's no reason to suppose a fan of Tolkien's will enjoy Martin's style.

On the positive side: Martin is a very good writer. The plot is intricate and epic, and the dialogue is far beyond the vast, vast majority of fantasy novels. As well as that he's writing for the adult market; there's plenty of adult humour and situations, while there's a goodly, but not gratutious amount of swearing. It all adds to the realism of the book. You really get the sense that you're reading a warts and all account of a bygone era. Too often fantasy writers aim for the young adult end of the market and end up offering up incipid novels in which nobody (even the most hardened warriors) ever curses, has sex or uses the toilet.

On the negative side: Martin is far better at the 'swords' end of the 'swords and sorcery' business, to the extent that the 'magical' elements of the story (such as they are), feel out of place. It's rather like reading a blood and guts account of the Wars of the Roses when all of a sudden a warlock shows up. The sections that involve magical elements are by far the weakest parts of the book.

And one MAJOR gripe I have is that for all his skills with words, Martin's characters seem utterly incapable of using more than two words to describe the male and female genitals (a hint, they're both 'C' words). It's not a matter of prudishness, it's simply that the English language contains an unbelievable wealth of words for human anatomy and yet Martin can't seem to get away from those two terms. In every intimate scene between two characters whether higborn or peasant, male or female etc. they all talk like sailors. Indeed none of the sex scenes in the first two books are very appealing. Rather than offering a tender riposte to the savagery on display in the rest of the book, sex is rough and unpleasant throughout.

That said the good parts far outweigh the bad, and it's a fantastic series of books so far; captivating, well plotted, and well worth investing time in.

Female Fantasy Fanatic
Wales
21st April 2008

Bad books? I DON'T THINK SO!!!
Thoroughly, totally, utterly brillient. The entire set are.


This is all.

Leon Clements
Southampton, England
18th April 2008

Sublime
What a truly brilliant read. Martin's world is perhaps not as large as those you'll find in other series, but it's depth and detail makes this more epic than any other. I believe this is the book 'true fantasy fans' want to read. Don't expect hollywood here, suggestion and understatement rule. Mature, cruel and unforgiving, like life itself you are rarely granted justice for the characters you love, but when you do, you remember why you love this man's work, and why you read fantasy at all. Intriguing until the last page and beyond. Superb.

If you can level one criticism at A Song of Ice and Fire, it's the sheer number of characters, each with their own carefully constructed history and family tree that you simply cannot map in your head until you go back and read it again.

Big Jim
London, UK
13th December 2007

"Epics" are for holidays
I've picked this up three times now and put it down each time, having been unable to devote the necessary time I feel it needs to get into. Having been off work for a while I gave it the fourth and final chance...and just made it to the end. Someone else makes the point that as a "midpoint" book in a series there are new threads starting and old ones ending but this volume just doesn't seem to go anywhere and having just read and thoroughly enjoyed Scott Lynch and Joe Abercrombie (The New Wave anyone?) I feel that the days of the bloated "character" driven epic may be numbered as (relatively) short, action packed series may be the way ahead.
I am of the increasing opinion that the propensity of fantasy books to be trilogies at least, and often running into huge long series (Malazan books for instance) lets authors off the hook to a great extent as they can ramble on knowing that there is a loyal following out there who HAVE invested the time and effort to get right into these books. I've made the point elsewhere that War and Peace is somehow seen as an imposing piece of work yet it is about a tenth the size of the Wheel of Time series for example! Go figure.
Having said all that I WILL carry on with the rest of this series as even as I write I am curious as to what happens next, so that's an accolade for Mr Martin...but I'll wait for the holidays before taking up that challenge.